Types of energy storage

General


Electrical energy cannot be stored directly. Electrical energy can be indirectly stored by converting the electrical energy to some other form of energy ("storage" energy). When a supply of electrical energy is required, the storage energy is reconverted back to electrical energy. Large quantities of "storage" energy are difficult to store and reconvert

Energy storage technologies allow generation facilities to be more evenly utilised. Additional electrical energy generated during off-peak hours (i.e. when there is spare generating capacity and the cost of electricity is lower) can be converted and stored, then reconverted for use during peak hours (when electricity can be sold at a premium). In this type of application, energy storage concepts are economical when the costs of the energy storage system's construction, operation and maintenance are offset by the differential between peaking and base-load energy costs. Energy storage systems could also be justified if they are more economic than new generating capacity that would be used only during times of peak load.

If economically competitive, storage systems may also be useful in combination with intermittent energy sources, a common trait of many renewable energy sources. The most common example of this is a system that utilises the excess electricity from a photovoltaic array to charge a battery during daylight hours, then draws off the battery during the night. Furthermore, storage systems may produce additional system advantages, such as spinning reserve, and area frequency and voltage control.The most widely used energy storage systems are pumped hydroelectric storage systems, batteries and compressed air storage systems. An energy storage system under development is based on regenerative fuel cell technology. Other developmental storage technologies include superconducting magnets and flywheels, but these will not be discussed here.

Pumped Hydro-electric Storage


In the pumped hydroelectric storage concept, such as that employed at Wivenhoe power station in Queensland, electrical energy from the electricity supply network is used to pump water from a lower level water storage to a higher level water storage. The electrical energy is therefore stored as the gravitational potential energy of the water in the upper storage.

When required, the water in the upper storage is released and flows through a turbine on its way back to the lower storage. The potential energy in the water is reconverted into electrical energy again by the turbine / generator.

Because of losses and inefficiencies in the elements of this system, the storage efficiency could be as low as 70%.

Note: Storage efficiency = Electrical Energy Output / Total Electrical Energy Input

Battery Storage

A battery storage system comprises the battery, dc/ac converter, charger, transformer, ac switchgear and a building to house these components.

Battery energy storage systems have several advantages in addition to their load levelling capability. Because battery systems can be added to in small increments, they offer a means of matching load growth. Battery storage systems also have dynamic source benefits because they provide spinning reserve, area frequency and voltage control, and increased system reliability. Because of their small sizes and because battery storage systems are environmentally compatible in virtually any area, they can be located near the loads, with a consequential reduction in system losses.

A disadvantage of battery storage systems is the high initial cost. Also, batteries using existing technologies require replacement every 8 to 10 years.

Currently, the only battery available for large energy storage applications is the lead-acid battery, which uses lead electrodes and a sulphuric acid electrolyte. Advanced batteries such as the sodium-sulphur and the zinc-bromine battery are being developed for this application.

Typical round trip (ac to ac) efficiencies are around 72%, made up of battery round trip (dc to ac) efficiencies of about 78% and power conditioning system efficiencies of about 94%.

Examples of large battery installations in operation are:

17 MW, 14.4 MWh in Germany; 21 MW, 14 MWh in Puerto Rico; and 10 MW, 40 MWh in USA.
Note: A 17 MW, 14.4 MWh system would be able to produce 17 MW of instantaneous electrical power and provide a total of 14.4 MWh of electrical energy before requiring a recharge.

Compressed Air Energy Storage

Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES) is a technology in which energy is stored in the form of compressed air in an underground cavern. Air is compressed during off-peak periods, stored in a cavern, and then used on demand during peak periods to generate power with a turbo-generator system.

A typical CAES unit consists of five basic components:

1. Compressor train (compressor, inter-coolers and after-cooler);
2. Motor Generator;
3. Turbine expander train (including expanders and combustors);
4. Recuperator; and
5. Underground cavern

Electricity from the grid powers an electric motor, which drives an air compressor. The heat generated by the compression process is extracted by inter-stage cooling and after cooling and stored. Most of the electric energy from the grid is therefore stored as the pressure potential energy of the compressed air in the cavern, with the small amount extracted by the compressor coolers is stored as heat energy.

When air is extracted from the cavern, it is first preheated in the recuperator. The recuperator reuses the energy extracted by the compressor coolers. The heated air is then mixed with small quantities of oil or gas, which is burned in the combustor. The hot gas from the combustor is expanded in the turbine to generate electricity.

The combustor and turbine components are identical to those used in a conventional gas turbine. However, instead of having to utilise some of its output to compress its air needed for combustion, all the power of the turbine can be used to generate electricity (its combustion air has already been compressed and stored). Less fuel is therefore required to generate the same quantity of electricity, resulting in a high thermal efficiency of the energy recovery stage. However, the overall cycle efficiency would be the ratio of the electrical energy generated to the total energy input (electrical energy from the grid + fuel energy).

An important performance parameter for a CAES system is the charging ratio, which is defined as the ratio of the electrical energy required to charge the system versus the electrical energy generated during discharge (the number of kWh input in charging to produce 1 kWh output). A low charging ratio results in low off-peak electrical energy requirements during the charging cycle.

Fast start-up is an advantage of CAES. A CAES plant can provide a start-up time of about 9 minutes for an emergency start, and about 12 minutes under normal conditions. By comparison, conventional combustion turbine peaking plants typically require 20 to 30 minutes for a normal start-up.

A significant contributor to the cost of a CAES system is the construction of the underground cavern. Three types of geological formations used for compressed air storage are salt dome, aquifer and rock caverns. Two of these are illustrated below.

In addition to the geological formation classifications, there are two classes of cavern design concepts, constant volume (also called un-compensated) and constant pressure (also called compensated). In a constant volume cavern, the air pressure is allowed to drop as air is withdrawn from storage. In a constant pressure cavern, water from a surface reservoir displaces the compressed air to maintain a constant pressure in the cavern.

The first commercial scale CAES plant in the world is the 290MW Huntorf, Germany, plant operated by Nordwest Deutsche Kraftwerke (NDK) since 1978. The Huntorf plant runs on a daily cycle in which it charges the air storage for 8 hours and provides generation for 2 hours. The plant has reported high availability of 86% and a starting reliability of 98%. The Huntorf plant has a salt cavern.

The Alabama Electric Co-operative, Inc, in McIntosh, Alabama built the second commercial scale CAES plant. This plant has the maximum existing CAES cavern capacity of around 1.8 million cubic metres. It began operation in 1991 and provides 110 MW of power generation. The cavern for the McIntosh plant was mined from a salt dome by dissolving salt with fresh water. The cavern which is 70m in diameter, 305m tall and 460m below grade, supplies compressed air supporting generation of 100MW for 26 hours. The CAES plant has a full load nett plant heat rate of 4819 kJ/kWh (74.7 % thermal efficiency) with a charging ratio of 1.3.

In addition to the NDK and the McIntosh CAES facilities, a 35MW CAES unit is under construction in Japan. Israel also has a 100MW CAES unit under construction, which uses an aquifer cavern for storage.

The Regenerative Fuel Cell Energy Storage System

There are several methods to used chemical energy as the form of energy storage. One of the most commercially advanced of these is the regenerative fuel cell technology.

The regenerative fuel cell, (sometimes known as redox flow cell technology) converts electrical energy into chemical potential energy by 'charging' two liquid electrolyte solutions. This chemical energy is converted back to electrical energy on discharge.
Regenerative fuel cell systems store or release electrical energy by means of a reversible electrochemical reaction between two salt solutions (the electrolytes). The reaction occurs within an electrochemical cell. The cell has two compartments, one for each electrolyte, physically separated by an ion-exchange membrane. In contrast to most types of battery system, the electrolytes flow into and out of the cell through separate manifolds and are transformed electrochemically inside the cell.

A commercial application of this system is the Regenesys™ system. This system has a high speed of response, supplies real and reactive power and is therefore suited to many different applications on a power system. The first Regenesys™ system is expected to be operational in 2002 at Little Barford. It will be used in conjunction with an adjacent combined cycle gas turbine power station to meet power requirements. The plant is designed to store 120 MWh of energy and discharge it at a nominal power rating of 15 MW.

Electricity Generation

The electricity production process involves, in simple terms, the conversion of energy from a (primary) energy source to electrical energy.

There are many sources of energy that may be used and many types of energy conversion processes. It is important to distinguish between the primary energy source and the energy conversion processes because some primary energy sources can be used in several types of energy conversion processes. Conversely, some energy conversion processes can be used to convert several different sources of primary energy.

Energy Conversion Processes


This section will look in particular at the energy conversion processes. These processes can be grouped in several ways, but the following grouping is used here:

Conversion of Rotational Energy in a rotating generator;

A rotating generator is the most common means of generating electricity. The various methods used to develop the rotational energy are discussed.

Electricity Generation By Conversion of Rotational Energy

Turbines - Steam Turbines , Hot Gas Turbines , Water Turbines , Wind Reciprocating Engines
This section provides brief discussions on how rotational energy can be produced, with emphasis on turbines & reciprocating engines.

The Generator


Before turbines are discussed, it is pertinent to give some mention to the item of equipment fundamental to the conversion of rotating energy into electrical energy and is the final link in the energy conversion process which commenced with the energy source - the generator.

The major generator components are the stator, rotor and frame.

The stator, as the name implies, is the stationary portion of a generator and consists of a core and windings. The stator winding provides the generator output voltage and current and which is connected to the electric power system.

The rotor of the generator is connected to the turbine, either directly or through a gearbox. It carries the rotating electric field into which direct current is introduced to produce the electromagnetic field and which is used to convert mechanical energy to electrical energy in the stator. The amount of direct current required is produced by an excitation system.

The generator frame supports the weight of the stator and rotor and acts as a containment vessel for the coolant gas, which is usually hydrogen for large machines.

Rotational Energy

Rotational energy is the kinetic energy possessed by a spinning shaft. The shaft is made to spin by fluid energy imparted to components attached to it. In the case of a turbine, the components are blades which are driven by a fluid which may be air, water, gas or steam. In the case of a reciprocating engine, the components are pistons and connecting rods driven by internal combustion forces.

Turbines

The main component of any turbine is the rotor. This is mechanically connected to the rotor of the generator which produces the electrical power output from the generator stator. All turbine rotors may be considered to be generically similar in that they all consist of a shaft with blades attached. The actual detailed design of the rotor is, however, quite different depending upon the properties of the fluid which drives it.

The turbine rotors for steam, hot gas, water and wind turbines are very different with respect to size, blade shape and materials. For example, the rotor of a steam turbine has many blades and is much smaller in diameter than the rotor of a wind turbine which may only have three blades made from a quite different material. The operating duty is quite different also and depends upon the ease of starting and stopping the turbine, the time involved in reaching full load and the life consumed each start.

Reciprocating Engines

Reciprocating engines and their use in electricity generation.


Conversion of Chemical Energy in a Fuel Cell or Battery;

A battery converts chemical energy into electrical energy through an electrochemical process involving stored materials. Fuel Cells are devices that convert a fuel to electricity also by electrochemical means.

Conversion of Electromagnetic Radiation (Solar Energy) in a Photo Voltaic cell (which produces an electrical potential when exposed to light) or by heating a working fluid in an electricity generating cycle;

Conversion of Kinetic Energy by the MagnetoHydroDynamic (MHD) process in which the flow of a conducting plasma through a static magnetic field produces an electrical current.

Reference
Web site
:
http://www.energy.qld.gov.au/electricity/infosite/index.htm

Back